Thailand politics: 4 ways Prayuth Chan-ocha’s suspension might play out

The Constitutional Court is set to rule on former junta chief Prayuth’s fate – but that could take months, and he has other options in the meantime
Will he resign before a ruling is made? Or could the court drag out the process all the way until the government’s term ends in March next year?

Thailand

Bloomberg

Published: 10:08am, 29 Aug 2022

Why you can trust SCMP

Thailand’s Constitutional Court surprised the nation last week by suspending Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha, a former army chief who first took power in a 2014 coup and stayed on following an election five years later.

The court, whose members were largely picked by a military-appointed Senate, took the action while it deliberates on whether Prayuth exceeded an eight-year term limit added into the post-coup constitution.

That provision was intended to prevent popular elected leaders from holding power too long, particularly after the army forcibly removed Thaksin Shinawatra in 2006 and his sister, Yingluck Shinawatra, in 2014.

02:23

Thai Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha suspended from official duties pending term-limit review

The court’s move has fuelled speculation that Thailand’s royal establishment is looking to replace Prayuth ahead of an election that must be called by March 2023.

Although election rules still favour the military-backed group to retain power, it faces stiff competition against the Pheu Thai party backed by Thaksin, whose allies have won the most seats in every national vote over the past 21 years.

“The power that Prayuth seized eight years ago has very much declined,” said Prinya Thaewanarumitkul, a law professor at Thammasat University. “The suspension came despite previous favourable rulings in the coupmaker’s favour, making people anxious about what’s going to happen next.”

Can exiled former Thai leader Thaksin sway redshirts to oust Prayuth in 2023 election?

Here’s how the situation may play out over the next few months:

1. Prayuth returns after court gives him the thumbs-up

A favourable court ruling for Prayuth means he can immediately stay on as prime minister and complete his four-year term in March. But the decision will still help decide whether he remains the ruling party’s candidate heading into the next election.

If the court says Prayuth’s term started in June 2019, when he was named prime minister of a civilian government, then he can still serve another full four-year term. But if it puts the start date at April 2017, when the constitution became effective, then it makes it more likely he’ll be replaced by the ruling party before the next vote.

Polls show Prayuth is deeply unpopular and the economy is on course for the slowest expansion in Southeast Asia this year. An opinion poll published in June showed Prayuth significantly behind Pheu Thai’s Paetongtarn Shinawatra, who is Thaksin’s daughter.

Paetongtarn Shinawatra, on stage in front of a picture with her father Thaksin, at a rally in the northern Thai province of Chiang Rai earlier this month. Photo: Handout

2. Court rules Prayuth must leave as term limit exceeded

A ruling against Prayuth means that he’ll immediately lose power and no political party can nominate him as a prime minister candidate in the next election. The cabinet would also need to step down and serve as caretakers until parliament picks a new leader. Legal experts are split on whether Prayuth can stay on as caretaker, saying the constitution doesn’t give clarity on this point.

One potential issue for the military establishment is who would immediately replace Prayuth. The House of Representatives and the Senate must select a new leader from a list approved before the 2019 polls, and Prayuth was the only military-friendly candidate.

In Thailand, having a regular job could still leave you US$218,000 in debt

If none of the other candidates get more than half the votes, then parliament can nominate others with the support of two-thirds of the combined National Assembly. One choice may be Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwon, another former army chief who is now serving as caretaker prime minister while Prayuth is suspended.

This scenario may affect Thailand’s global image, given that the country is set to host world leaders including at a summit of Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation economies in November. Foreign Minister Don Pramudwinai has said the suspension won’t affect Thailand’s plans for the event.

Prawit Wongsuwon pictured on Tuesday last week. The fellow ex-army chief is currently serving as caretaker prime minister while Prayuth is suspended. Photo: EPA-EFE

3. Prayuth resigns before court makes its ruling

By law, Prayuth can resign as prime minister at any time – even during his suspension. This means the whole cabinet would step into a caretaker capacity until lawmakers and the Senate select a new prime minister.

In this scenario, legal experts are not all in agreement on whether Prayuth becomes interim prime minister given he has been suspended. Prawit would therefore likely stay on as caretaker after Prayuth resigns.

If the establishment had wanted Prayuth to step down, his resignation ahead of the decision would’ve been more graceful way

Yuttaporn Issarachai, Thai political scientist

Still, this scenario is considered unlikely since Prayuth could’ve already heeded protester demands and left before his suspension.

“If the establishment had wanted Prayuth to step down, his resignation ahead of the decision would’ve been more graceful way with the display of his political spirit,” said Yuttaporn Issarachai, a political scientist at Sukhothai Thammathirat Open University.

Protesters rally outside government house in Bangkok last week to demand Prayut Chan-ocha’s resignation Photo: SOPA Images via ZUMA Press Wire/dpa

4. Court delays ruling on Prayuth’s case until next elections

There isn’t a set time for when the Constitutional Court must issue a ruling, raising the possibility that it could drag out the process all the way until the government’s term ends in March next year.

In practice, this risks fuelling further frustration among voters and could spark protests.

Thailand’s Prayuth hails Khao soi after it’s named world’s best soup

It would also leave Prayuth’s status unclear heading into the next election, raising the prospect that the ruling party opts for another candidate to end the uncertainty.

Analysts have said it wouldn’t make sense to delay the verdict for longer than two months given his suspension is likely to have been aimed at lowering the political temperature in Thailand.

Post