avatar image
Advertisement

Hong Kong elections: by delaying vote for one year, leader throws up raft of legal and political questions

  • It remains unclear if opposition lawmakers already disqualified from running will be permitted or even want to take part in an extended term
  • Basic Law expert Maria Tam casts doubt over whether a prolonged Legco can survive legal challenges

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
0
Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam believes the most pragmatic way forward is to extend the legislature’s current term for one year. Illustration: SCMP
The announcement by Hong Kong’s leader to postpone the Legislative Council elections for a year leaves a raft of questions unanswered, including whether lawmakers already disqualified from the polls can continue to serve and if extended emergency sessions can survive legal challenge.

The delay also scrambles the political landscape for the opposition, which must now decide whether to take part in a provisional term during which controversial legislation could be passed.

Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor cited the risk posed by the coronavirus pandemic in announcing Legco elections originally slated for September 6 would be delayed for a year. Lam said she had submitted an emergency report to the State Council in Beijing, which informed her that the central government would ask China’s top legislative body, the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress (NPC), to make a decision on the outstanding legal and constitutional issues.

03:39

Hong Kong Legislative Council elections postponed by a year

Hong Kong Legislative Council elections postponed by a year

Lam believed “the most pragmatic” way forward was to extend Legco’s current term, which expires on September 30, for one year.

Under the Legislative Council Ordinance, the chief executive must specify a date for holding general elections not earlier than 60 days and not later than 15 days before the new term of office.

The Legco president can convene emergency meetings after September 30, at the request of the chief executive, and such a session can be held before general elections of an unspecified date. Incumbent lawmakers will be deemed members of the legislature.

But Maria Tam Wai-chu, vice-chairwoman of the Basic Law Committee that advises Beijing on Hong Kong’s mini-constitution, said such a move would be subject to legal challenge as some might question whether such meetings could truly be deemed to be of an emergency nature.

Gary Cheung joined the Post in 2000, covering fields ranging from politics and the integration between Hong Kong and China. He became assistant editor-in-chief of Ming Pao in 2017 and returned to the Post the following year. He is author of Hong Kong’s Watershed: The 1967 riots (Hong Kong University Press, 2009).
Kimmy Chung joined the Post in 2017 and reports for the Hong Kong desk on local politics and Hong Kong-mainland issues. Prior to joining the Post, she covered Hong Kong politics and social policies for more than six years for different media outlets.
Natalie is an award-winning journalist specialising in policy analysis with a focus on Hong Kong politics. She also moderates SCMP events and is passionate about video storytelling. She is the co-author of Post Portraits – Hong Kong’s 25 years of change through the lens of the South China Morning Post (SCMP Publishers, 2023). Previously, she worked for i-Cable News (HK) and BBC Chinese (London).
Advertisement