Sitting alongside Pusateri, friend Davide Penna concurred. “I still can’t believe it has happened,” he said. “We have never experienced anything like this. It’s over.”

Similar sentiments were voiced by fans coming out of the San Siro stadium in Milan after Monday’s 0-0 draw.

“I am disappointed with the whole football system in Italy,” said Mirko Palmieri. “It is the umpteenth failure of our country. Even here (at the San Siro), we can’t get the job done.”

Italy not being at the World Cup will be a new experience for most of the country’s fans, and few of them are looking forward to the experience of watching from the sidelines.

The four-time champions opted not to play at the first World Cup in 1930 but they have been present at every other edition apart from 1958, when they also failed to qualify.

“I was born with Italy being a part of the World Cup, and it has always been like that,” one supporter said on his way out of the Milan stadium.

“Tomorrow I will wake up and my life will go on but this summer I will do something else.”

Another added: “The disappointment is a double one – first because we are not good, but second because we were beaten by a team that is even worse than us.”

Back in the Rome bar, the view that Italy deserved to be on the plane to Russia was disputed by journalism student Christian Dalenz.

“The reality is they were not good enough, they haven’t earned the right to be at the World Cup. This is a very weak squad. It just does not have enough world-class players who can make the difference.”

The extent of the shock that non-qualification represents for Italian football was underlined by the pre-match confidence of most fans that Gigi Buffon and co. would pull through.

“It is not as if Sweden are that strong a team,” Fabio Votano, a Roman, who was only a toddler when Italy last missed out on a World Cup finals, had said hours before kick-off.

“Not winning is completely unthinkable, basically something that has never happened before. For Italy, getting to the World Cup finals is almost a duty.”

Italy ended up in the play-offs as a result of finishing second in their qualifying group behind Spain.

They then put in a sluggish performance in the first leg in Sweden, when the home side edged a scrappy, physical affair thanks to substitute Jakob Johansson’s deflected shot just after the hour mark.

Rome resident Enrico Doddi insisted Italy’s players were good enough to have overcome Sweden.

“They’re playing miserably at the moment but Italy still has a good set of players in my opinion,” he said. “It is all down to mentality.

“You cannot have a good World Cup without Italy.”