avatar image
Advertisement

Opinion | Graffiti, arson, death threats: in Australia, violence against mosques is widespread

  • After the 2019 attack in Christchurch, New Zealand, researchers surveyed mosques in Australia to gauge the extent of anti-Muslim attacks
  • Their work suggests attacks on Australia mosques are neither new nor rare. But only the most egregious cases come to public attention

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
13
Al Noor mosque in Christchurch, New Zealand, where more than 40 people were killed by an Australian extremist during Friday prayers on March 15, 2019. Photo: George Heard/New Zealand Herald
The horrendous mass murders in New Zealand on March 15 2019 had a strong link with Australia.
The New Zealand royal commission into the attacks found the Australian perpetrator had long subscribed to violent right-wing Islamophobia and had taken this with him to New Zealand. In fact, Muslim communities in New Zealand had reported threats and violence for years, including suspicious behaviour at one of the mosques targeted in Christchurch.

After the Christchurch attack, we surveyed mosques in Australia to gauge the extent of anti-Muslim attacks in the country. We cannot understand the Christchurch massacre without comprehending the Australian context that at least in part incubated it.

Our research finds the threat of similarly motivated acts of hatred remains widespread. During 2020, we surveyed 75 mosques from five states and two territories of Australia about their experiences of violence in the five years from 2014 to 2018, as well as detailed questions about 2019. About half of the responses were from imams or mosque officials, 15 per cent from volunteers and 35 per cent from other congregation members.

03:10

Families and friends grieve for Christchurch terror attack victims

Families and friends grieve for Christchurch terror attack victims

Most concerning is that more than half (58.2 per cent) of participating mosques – or worshippers at them – had experienced targeted violence between 2014 and 2019. The threat of an attack increased in cases where there had been public attention. For example, 100 per cent of mosques that were reported in the media experienced higher rates of victimisation, as did 83 per cent of those that had experienced online opposition to their development.

The types of violence suffered by mosque attendees and the mosque buildings included arson, physical assault, graffiti, vandalism, verbal abuse and online abuse and hate mail, including death threats. There were notable geographical differences in these occurrences of violence. Despite being home to more mosques, Sydney saw fewer attacks, proportionally, (41 per cent of 51 mosques) between 2014 and 2018 than Melbourne (70 per cent of 17 mosques) and Brisbane (89 per cent of nine mosques). The proportion of attacks against mosques in Australian states and territories was 29 per cent in 2019, in the wake of the Christchurch massacre. Again, these were disproportionately distributed between the states, with a higher proportion of attacks directed at mosques in Brisbane and Melbourne.

Scott Poynting is Adjunct Professor in the Centre for Islamic Studies and Civilisation at Charles Sturt University. His areas of interest include Islamophobia, the criminalisation of ethnic minorities and the racialisation of crime, state terrorism, hate crime, and racialised moral panic. He has worked since the mid-1990s on the criminalisation of Arab immigrants in Australia, and since 2001 has turned his attention to anti-Muslim racism and especially hate crime, and to state terrorism in the context of the ‘war on terror’.
Dr Derya Iner is a senior lecturer and research coordinator at the Centre for Islamic Studies and Civilisation, Charles Sturt University. She was the chief investigator of the Islamophobia in Australia Reports I (2017) and II (2019). She is also an executive board member of the Islamophobia Register Australia. Her research focuses on Islamophobia, especially women and children’s experience with Islamophobia, Western Muslim Youth and their religious identity.
Professor Nicole L. Asquith has worked as a practitioner and academic in the areas of interpersonal violence and policing vulnerability. Her doctoral research looked at the forensic possibilities of hate speech in hate crime, and was later extended through the analysis of 100,000 hate crimes reported to the London Metropolitan Police Service. She currently works with Australian policing and criminal justice agencies to address the issues raised by violent victimisation, and responding to victims', offenders' and practitioners' vulnerabilities. She is also the head of discipline for policing and emergency management at the University of Tasmania, co-director of the Vulnerability, Resilience and Policing Research Consortium, Research Associate with the Sexualities and Genders Research Network, and secretary of the Australian Hate Crime Network.
Ron Mason
Ron Mason has over 20 years practical experience in market, social research and evaluation, with projects undertaken at local, state and national levels, and within the public and private sectors. He has a specific interest and experience in social problems and social policy. As a research associate with the Criminological Research Unit and a senior researcher with the Tasmanian Institute of Law Enforcement, he has managed and conducted numerous research projects in a variety of fields including sociology, criminology, health, and education.
Advertisement