Advertisement
Advertisement
Indonesia
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Prabowo Subianto speaks during the final presidential debate in Jakarta on Sunday. Photo: Bloomberg

Indonesia election 2024: Prabowo takes flak for ‘slow brains’ remark, anti-disability rhetoric in final debate

  • Prabowo, whose running mate is the president’s son, used Sunday’s final debate to again promote his multibillion-dollar plan to provide free meals
  • He denied making a ‘very cruel’ comment about voters’ intelligence while campaigning, even as he implied that the disabled were not ‘normal people’
Indonesia
Less than two weeks before voters head to the polls to choose Indonesia’s next leader, presidential front runner Prabowo Subianto found himself on the defensive following the final televised debate.

Three presidential hopefuls faced off on Sunday to discuss issues ranging from health to employment, culture, information technology, social welfare, and inclusion.

Prabowo, the current defence minister, used the opportunity to again promote his US$25.4 billion programme of free meals for schoolchildren and pregnant mothers.

Ganjar Pranowo speaks at the debate on Sunday. He criticised as “very cruel” a statement Prabowo reportedly made about voters’ intelligence. Photo: Bloomberg
The scheme’s stated aim is to prevent malnutrition and stunted growth in children, but fellow presidential hopeful Ganjar Pranowo attacked the idea for being an intervention that would come “too late”.

“We should start checking the health of future brides and grooms,” said the ruling Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle’s (PDI-P) candidate and former Central Java governor.

“We need to pay attention to their ages too,” he added, saying he agreed with Indonesia’s current minimum age of 19 for marriage “as it means that they are mentally and physically developed”.

Can Indonesia’s Ganjar force a run-off as bid for ‘total victory’ dries up?

Ganjar further criticised as “very cruel” a statement Prabowo reportedly made last month while on the campaign trail in Kalimantan: namely that “people who want free internet have slow brains”. Free internet is one of the flagship programmes Ganjar plans to implement if elected as President Joko Widodo’s successor.

“I didn’t say that,” Prabowo responded. “What I said was ‘which one is better, free internet or free meals, for poor people?’ I agree with free internet, but I won’t prioritise it over free meals, as poor people need to eat.”

Prabowo, whose running mate Gibran Rakabuming Raka is Widodo’s eldest son, has the perceived backing of the outgoing president despite not being the PDI-P’s candidate.
Over the past week, at least seven Indonesian universities have released statements urging Jokowi, as the president is popularly known, to stop meddling in the election – something he admitted last year he would do – and criticising democratic backsliding on his watch.
Outgoing President Joko Widodo has been criticised for meddling in Indonesia’s election. His son Gibran is Prabowo’s running mate. Photo: AFP

“We must oppose dynastic politics, which is supported by those who control a third of Indonesia’s wealth, and who prioritise family interests above everything else,” Ganjar said in his closing statement on Sunday, referring to the universities’ statements.

“Five years ago, in the 2019 presidential election, I was on Jokowi’s campaign team. We were reminded not to vote for candidates who had dictatorial traits, had a track record of violence, and human rights violations. I agreed with what he said.”

Prabowo – a former special forces commander who went into self-exile following the downfall of his father-in-law, the late dictator Suharto – has been accused of masterminding the kidnapping of student activists and political dissidents in 1998 and being involved in rights abuses in Papua and East Timor

He denies the allegations, which are unproven. Yet during a debate for the 2014 presidential election, the first of two he lost to Jokowi, Prabowo did say he had been “following an order from” Suharto.

From India to Indonesia, 2024 is Asia’s election year. But how much will anything change?

Ganjar appeared more critical of Prabowo’s programmes on Sunday than fellow contender Anies Baswedan, who had tried in previous debates to take the ex-general down a peg.

Noting that he was committed to tackling sexual violence and providing free day care for working mothers so that “women can have equal salaries to men”, the former Jakarta governor did question Prabowo on his planned policies to protect women.

Yet Anies mostly used his time to interrogate Ganjar on the recent intensive distribution of social aid for the needy days ahead of the election, which critics have seen as an attempt to sway poorer voters.

“Social assistance is assistance for the recipient, not assistance for the giver,” Anies said. “This social assistance is provided in the name of the state. When I was governor, all social assistance packages were labelled as funded by the Jakarta regional budget, not in the name of the governor.”

Anies Baswedan at Sunday’s presidential debate. The former Jakarta governor hit out at the recent distribution of social aid to the needy, which critics have called an electoral ploy. Photo: Bloomberg

Yohanes Sulaiman, a political analyst at the University of Ahmad Yani in West Java, described the final presidential debate as a “subdued” affair that had none of the “sparkle” of previous bouts.

The candidates’ talk of women’s rights was particularly “ironic”, he said.

“Despite all of the talk about ‘gender equality’, virtually all candidates only talk about women as ‘mothers’, as people who give birth to children, and that’s it. Nothing was said about their professional development as empowered women,” said Yohanes, who is an associate professor of international relations.

Meanwhile, Prabowo also took flak on Sunday for his comments about disabled people.

Still baffled, but not shocked, with Prabowo’s ableist statement in dichotomising ‘normal’ people and people with disability
Margianta SJD, social justice activist

In response to a question about how to improve their lives, he said: “we need to collaborate with outside parties to find technology to help people with disabilities. Now there is new technology that can help them live independently and be able to work closer to normal people.”

“Still baffled, but not shocked, with Prabowo’s ableist statement in dichotomising ‘normal’ people and people with disability,” social justice activist Margianta SJD wrote on the X social media platform.

In his closing statement, Prabowo apologised to his rivals for any “unpleasant acts” that had occurred during campaigning.

“Our desire is to do the best for Indonesia. I consider [my rivals] to be my brothers. If we receive a mandate from the people, we will be national leaders for all Indonesian people, including those who do not vote for me, and those who do not believe in me,” he said.

Indonesian band changes tune on Jokowi, backs Ganjar to ‘keep democracy alive’

His apology was welcomed by supporters, including stand-up comedian Kiky Saputri, who said on X that she “thanks Prabowo for being so gentle and embracing everyone for the sake of harmony”. Others said it did not go far enough.

“I thought Prabowo [would] also apologise to the families of activists who are still missing,” Veronica Koman, an Indonesian human rights lawyer in exile in Australia, said on X.

5